 |
Not In Our Own Backyards? by Alexis Eastman For your perusal, two truncated medical cases, complete with jargon, which is, for the most part irrelevant.
Case 1
CC: Z.M. is a 36 y.o. married woman, P 3-0-0-3, who presents at the clinic with a regular cough and shortness of breath.
HPI: Cough is dry, deep and non-productive. Onset approximately 2 months ago. In past three weeks, Z.M. has experienced increased shortness of breath, and air hunger when supine. Cough now occurs at least once and hour, for several minutes at a time. She is only at the clinic because she can no longer work on her family farm productively. Z.M. states that she must stop to catch her breath every ten to fifteen minutes. She reports no other symptoms – no swelling, pain, itchiness, sputum, or blood. She has not used any OTC cough suppressants because she lives too far from a pharmacy.
PH: All 3 children born at home, now aged 7, 9, and 12. She and husband have a small farm, and sell produce at the local market. She does not know her immunization status. This is her first time at a medical clinic of any sort . She reports no EtOH or tobacco use. She reports NKA, no other health problems in past. Both her parents are deceased, but she does not think any diseases run in the family.
PE: Ht 163 cm, Wt 49 kg, Resp 34, BP 140/92, radial pulse 86 and +3. Upon examination, skin is normal, nasal tissue is pink and normal, no tenderness upon palpation of maxillary sinuses. Pharynx appears normal with no tonsillar swelling. No occipital, post-auricular, pre-auricular, submandibular, submental or supraclavicular nodes present. Axillary nodes present on left side, approximately 2 cm. Lung sounds are wet, and percussion of the lower left lobe was dense.
DX: Suspected carcinoma of the lung. Z.M. cannot be sent for X-ray or biopsy because such services are generally unavailable for her. Will inform patient of what needs to be done for further follow-up, but expected compliance will likely be low. Will refer Z.M. to volunteer social worker for help with financial services.
Case 2
CC: K.V. is a 42 y.o. married woman, P 4-0-0-2, who presents at the clinic with a regular cough and shortness of breath.
HPI: Cough is wet and productive. Onset approximately 2 months ago. In past three weeks, K.V. has experienced increased shortness of breath, and air hunger when supine. Cough now occurs at least once and hour, for several minutes at a time. She is only at the clinic because she can no longer work on her family farm productively. K.V. states that she must stop to catch her breath every ten to fifteen minutes. Occasional blood in sputum. Pain in chest is 2, and dull with no radiations. She has lost 2 kg in the past month, and reports a loss of appetite. She reports one episode of fever and occasional night sweats/chills. She has not used any OTC medications because she lives too far from a pharmacy.
PH: All 4 children born at home, one stillborn, one died age 1, remaining are 16 and 14 y.o. She and husband have a small farm, and sell produce at the local market. She does not know her immunization status. This is her first time at a medical clinic of any sort. She reports no EtOH or tobacco use. She reports NKA, no other health problems in past. Both her parents are deceased, but she does not think any diseases run in the family.
PE: Ht 163 cm, Wt 49 kg, Resp 34, BP 140/92, radial pulse 86 and +3. Upon examination, skin is diaphoretic, nasal tissue is pink and normal, no tenderness upon palpation of maxillary sinuses. Pharynx appears raw but with no tonsillar swelling. No nodes present. Lung sounds are crackling upon inspiration and percussion of the upper right lobe was dense.
DX: Suspected pneumonia or TB. K.V. cannot be sent for X-ray and culture cannot be taken because such services are generally unavailable for her. Will put K.V. on DOT+ as safety measure. Will inform patient of what needs to be done for further follow-up, but expected compliance will likely be low, as no nurse is available to monitor DOT+, and unsure of local resources. Will refer K.V. to volunteer social worker for help with financial services.
******
I made these cases up, but they are completely plausible. What’s interesting is that I wrote one of them to describe a woman in Uganda, and another to describe a legal, documented immigrant in the United States. Both of these women will probably be dead within a year. Do you know which is which? To be honest, I can only tell because I wrote them – otherwise, they’re completely plausible.
Lack of health care in Africa surprises no one. Lack of health care in the U.S. is no longer much of a shock, either. However, while there were 239 doctors for every 100,000 people in the U.S. in 2001, there are 5 doctors per 100,000 people in Uganda. On a slow day in the U.S., a primary care doctor will see 5 patients and go home early. On a slow day in Uganda, a primary care doctor will see 200 patients and go home early. And yet, these two women will receive exactly the same care, or lack thereof. One will get no care because the government doesn’t have the money to provide health care. One will get no care because the government doesn’t guarantee health care for all, and leaves an especially large gap for immigrants to fall through. Undocumented immigrants are in an even more precarious situation, and if like Case #2, an undocumented immigrant has possible tuberculosis and doesn’t get medical attention, she/he could infect hundreds of people before succumbing to the disease. Beyond that, in taking just the beginning of the course of antibiotics, that patient could grow and spread a drug-resistant form of tuberculosis, which are becoming increasingly hard to treat. Both women will die leaving young children in financial distress and prone to illness because if the husband’s working to make ends meet, there’s no one to take care of them. Neither woman purposely became ill, yet neither will receive any help unless there’s a local charity that can provide aid.
I’m not trying to stand on a soapbox about immigration. Regardless of what you feel the U.S. immigration policy should be, there are people here already who will get sick, and may create public health dangers through no fault of their own. And yet we will treat them as if we were Uganda. Indeed, we will be worse, for Uganda truly wants to spend more money on all its people – even a fraction of what we spend would be a blessing – while our country holds its enormous economic might out of reach of a large portion of its population. The cruel joke is that if a citizen of the United States moves to any other developed nation, they will receive health care, regardless of their citizenship. Even if the documented immigrant in my cases finally becomes a U.S. citizen, she may or may not qualify for health care depending on her relationship to the poverty line.
I realize there are all sorts of details that need to be worked out. Everyone’s afraid of a gargantuan chaotic system complete with interminable wait times and outdated technology (though I would like to point out that Japan has more contemporary medical technology per person than any other nation, and they have national health coverage). Truly, that would be awful. However, it’s a detail, and an easy distraction from the fact that at this point, there’s no large system to be afraid of. The only thing close to an all-encompassing health system is Medicare, which is one of the most streamlined programs in the government, with one of the smallest overheads. The danger of details is that we may spend so much time arguing them that we won’t actually do anything. Time will pass, private insurance will get more expensive and cover less, government programs will be reformatted in both good and bad ways, and there will be an increasing number of people who can’t access adequate health care. ERs will be even more overloaded, and no one will get to use the cutting edge technology because only the rich will be able to afford it. And people are worried about creating a gargantuan and chaotic system? No need to worry; it’s already here.
In the 1840s, the United States began creating the most egalitarian public primary education system in the world (it wasn’t truly egalitarian, it was just more so than everyone else’s systems at the time). But for some reason, we lost the public health drive that went along with it, making it less of an individual responsibility for the good of society and more of a government office introducing policies from far away. And we decided, oddly, that while children should read and write they don’t necessarily deserve to be healthy. Not that the education system is flawless or static. We’ve been arguing about the details of the education system since its inception. And it’s getting a bit old, frankly. There are only so many times you can listen to debates on phonics language systems, after all. But at least there’s a system to argue about. We need a new system to argue about for the next two centuries. Let’s make it universal health care.
April 25, 2007
|
 |
|
| |
Miscellaneous
Archive
|
|
| |
Hiatus by The Editors Hi folks,So you may have noticed - we haven't had much new content in a while. We really love LostWriters, and we feel very passionately about it being a community and a forum for writers and artists of all bents, but for the mome [ Read more... ] This Doesn't Look Different... by The Editors Hello loyal readers! Yes, we are back, and yes, we aren't done with our revamp of the website. You see, we got lots of suggestions from you, and it's been hard working out which ones we can do, and which ones require mil [ Read more... ] We're Taking a Break by The Lost Editors Dear Lost Readers, The astute among you, or those just gifted with the ability to see, may have noticed a decline in the number of new articles posted to LostWriters over the last several months. Perhaps, this has concerned you. Perh [ Read more... ] Confessions of a Wedding Virgin by Meghan Purvis I’m twenty-five years old and I have never been to a wedding. I promise, I do actually have friends—weddings have occurred in my various social circles over the years, and I’ve even [ Read more... ] Near Life Experience: In a Parallel Universe Part III by Holly Hagan Continued.My mom said I should think of Daniel as my brother, and that I shouldn’t show him how to do bad things. In a parallel u [ Read more... ] |
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|